December 2002
Newsletter
By BISHOP DR. MUNIB A. YOUNAN
Salaam
and grace to you from Jerusalem, the city of Christ's death and
resurrection.
Bishop
Younan and the whole ELCJ send you blessed Advent and Christmas
greetings. In this land of Jesus' birth we are lighting the Advent
candles, remembering God's promises of a Savior and preparing
for the Feast of the Nativity.
1. Observing
Advent in the Militarily Occupied Cities
On the first Sunday in Advent, Dec. 1, Bishop Younan brought a
group from the New England and Southeast Michigan Synods of the
Evangelical Lutheran Church in America to the ELCJ church in Beit
Jala for worship. These two ELCA synods are partners with the
ELCJ and were here to make solidarity visits. Ordinarily the trip
to Bethlehem would not be too difficult, despite the hardships
of Israel's military occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
However, the whole Bethlehem area (including Beit Jala and Beit
Sahour) is once again under a lockdown order. Israel considers
the area to be a closed military zone. The Palestinian people
have been under curfew, basically house arrest, for several weeks.
Bishop Younan
had been able to obtain papers from the Israeli military commander
to bring two vehicles with his family and the American visitors
into this closed military zone. The purpose of the visit was to
worship at the Lutheran Church of the Reformation in Beit Jala,
where the bishop was scheduled to conduct the service.
We entered
Bethlehem directly through the Bethlehem checkpoint, full of many
armed soldiers and military equipment. Driving through Bethlehem
with the vehicle flashers on, we made our way to the church through
empty streets, seeing only an occasional person outside a building.
Shops, businesses, schools and institutions were all closed. Arriving
at the Lutheran church in Beit Jala, we entered the church compound
and were greeted by people who live and work there.
About fifteen
minutes before the service was scheduled to begin, the church
bells were rung. Over the empty streets, into the homes of sequestered
people, into the ears of Christians and Muslims alike, the bells
rang out the message that worship would soon begin, refusing to
let human military laws take precedence over God's Word. The glad
sounds of the bells continued for at least five minutes, pealing
out the invitation to come and worship. Gradually people began
to gather and they continued to come all through the service conducted
by Bishop Younan and Bishop Margaret Payne of the ELCA New England
Synod, in the absence of Rev. Jadallah Shihadeh, who was abroad.
At least forty people, including the eight American visitors,
were singing together, hearing God's Word and visiting over coffee
after the service, despite the continued curfew and the Israeli
tanks rolling up and down the narrow street just outside the church
gate.
On the second
Sunday in Advent, Dec. 8, Bishop Younan again drove up to the
Israeli militarized Bethlehem checkpoint. With him were visitors
from Norway and Switzerland. This time he did not have special
papers but asked for admission to Bethlehem in order to worship
at the Christmas Lutheran Church. He was given entry and once
again, with flashers on, he drove through the empty streets. Arriving
at the Christmas Lutheran Church it was apparent the curfew was
very strict on this day because no one was outside walking or
shopping. The stores were all closed.
After the
bells had rung, worshippers began arriving and eventually twenty-five
to thirty local people from Bethlehem and Beit Jala were in attendance,
in addition to international visitors from America, Sweden, Germany,
Norway and Switzerland. Rev. Dr. Mitri Raheb, Rev. Sandra Olewine
and Bishop Younan conducted the service.
Just as the
second Advent candle was being lit, loud voices of Israeli soldiers
shouting repeatedly in broken Arabic could be heard in the marketplace,
directly outside the church door. "It is curfew! Those who
break curfew will be punished!" This warning applied to every
person in the church. Nevertheless, the service continued as people
worshipped, prayed, sang and listened to God's Word. Their hearts
were being prepared for the coming of the Christ.
The text for
Bishop Younan's sermon was from Luke 21. "Stand and raise
up your heads for your Redeemer is drawing near." The bishop
spoke of many misunder-standings regarding the Second Coming of
Christ. "Christian Zionists are making their own roadmaps
for Jesus. They have missed Jesus' message found in the biblical
texts. Jesus does not need a roadmap. His call to us in the Church
is to be prepared for his coming, to stand and raise up our heads."
The bishop told the congregation, "When you break the curfew
to worship, you are obeying God rather than the military occupation.
You are coming to prepare your hearts and minds for the coming
of Christ, and to get spiritual strength to be a Church of martyria."
The people
gathered for coffee and conversation following the service, a
great pleasure after more than two weeks of curfew. It is heartbreaking
to know that these people along with many other Christians and
their Muslim friends and neighbors are continually harassed in
their own homes and towns. The Muslim people missed out on the
joys and celebration of the Eid al Fitr which follows the end
of Ramadan. The Christians may miss out on the joys and celebration
of Christmas if the Israeli military lockdown continues as planned.
The people said their farewells, having been fed with spiritual
food and fellowship. As they left for their homes they were unsure
and uncertain about what would happen next.
Bishop Younan
has compared the situation to that of the Jewish exiles in Babylon
so many millennia ago. Their sorrow is expressed in Psalm 137:
"By the rivers of Babylon we wept when we remembered Zion.
. . . Those who created our suffering said, 'Sing to us the songs
of Zion,' but how can we sing a song in a strange land?"
Indeed, the bishop has commented, how can we sing our songs when
injustice has become a normal way of life here in Palestine, when
people are kept like hostages in their houses and towns?
2. School
Closures
Once again the schools have been closed in the Bethlehem area.
This involves three large ELCJ schools as well as many other Christian
and Muslim private schools and the public school system. The schools
in Ramallah were also closed for a few days but are now reopened.
Schools in other Palestinian cities such as Jenin and Nabus continued
to be closed because of lengthy Israeli-imposed curfews.
When our schools
are closed it is not only a matter of school days being lost at
this moment, important as that is. It is also a matter of destroying
the future for Palestinian people and their society. If children
cannot be educated, they will not be able to support themselves
economically, to make important political and societal decisions,
to make important contributions to the general society or even
to raise their own children with hopes and plans for the future.
But Palestinian people want their children to be educated, and
the children are eager to go to school.
We are receiving
reports from Nablus that innovative ways are being found to educate
the children in order to compensate for the school closures. "Street
schools" are open, bringing neighborhood children into nearby
homes for their lessons. Teachers from the schools who are also
under curfew are teaching children in the houses.
Right now
in the Bethlehem area, children are on the alert to come directly
to school as soon as the Israeli soldiers announce that the curfew
is being lifted for a few hours, for example, from 10 am to 4
pm. Adults hurry to go shopping and take care of family needs;
children and their teachers run for the schools. And even then,
as happened on Monday, Dec. 9, the curfew can be reimposed much
earlier than 4 pm, leaving everyone unfulfilled, with shopping,
schooling and visits to family once again forbidden. Please continue
to pray for all the children, teachers, schools, families and
churches caught in this deprivation of human rights. And please
pray that the curfews which close down the schools will be lifted
so Palestinian life can continue as normally as possible. Please
also pray that occupation may end and justice and security will
prevail.
3. A
Visit to Beirut, Lebanon
Bishop Younan is a member of the NEST board, the Near East School
of Theology, located in Beirut, Lebanon. This seminary was established
in the 1950s by the Anglican, Lutheran, Presbyterian and Armenian
Evangelical churches in the Middle East. Bishop Younan described
the board meetings as "normal," and was also happy to
make a number of contacts with religious leaders in Lebanon. He
preached in the National Presbyterian Church in Beirut, giving
the message of justification by grace through faith, and emphasizing
the necessity of implementing God's loving justice in our human
relationships. The bishop enjoyed visiting with the Presbyterian
pastor, Rev. Dr. Habib Badr.
Bishop Younan
also met with the Moderator of the World Council of Churches who
is the Patriarch of the Armenian Orthodox Church, His Beatitude
Catolicos Aram Keshishian. With His Beatitude, Bishop Younan had
fruitful discussions on the future of the ecumenical movement
in the Middle East, and the restructuring of the Middle East Council
of Churches. His Beatitude expressed his full solidarity with
the suffering people in the Middle East. Bishop Younan was very
encouraged that Middle East church leaders are committed to the
Church's prophetic role, promoting peace, justice and reconciliation.
Bishop Younan accompanied by Rev. Dr. Riad Jarjour also visited
with Cardinal Sfeir, the patriarch of the Maronite Church. The
patriarch expressed his solidarity with the Palestinian people
and with the Christian churches in Palestine. The importance of
the role of the Church in being prophetic by condemning the Israeli
occupation, the human rights violations and all violence was discussed.
Again it was reiterated that the Church must always be working
for peace, justice and reconciliation. Additional visits were
made by Bishop Younan with the Middle East Council of Churches
(MECC) general secretary and staff.
4. Returning
from Beirut via Amman, Jordan, to Jerusalem
Palestinian church leaders such as patriarchs, bishops and archbishops
have special papers and permissions given by the Israeli Ministry
of Religious Affairs to expedite their necessary and frequent
travel within the country and at the airport and bridges as they
leave and then return to the country. Bishop Younan has these
papers, but on Nov. 27th he once again experienced major delays
and harassment by Israeli security forces as he tried to return
to Jerusalem across the Allenby Bridge from Jordan. Instead of
being accorded the right of smooth passage, Bishop Younan was
searched, delayed and called for interrogation. The bishop would
not accept any interrogation. In a letter to the Israeli Minister
of Religious Affairs, Bishop Younan stated, "I felt my whole
experience was an insult and humiliation, not only for me but
for the whole Lutheran Church. I am well known to the Israeli
security forces as one of the thirteen heads of Christian churches
in Jerusalem. The treatment I received on November 27, 2002, at
the Allenby Bridge was deliberate. When I remember what happened
to me, I realize that it was a kind of persecution and direct
humiliation and harassment not only toward me and my Lutheran
Church but toward all the local Christian leaders and communities.
If I am treated in this way, then how are other local Christians
treated when they try to travel?" This letter was widely
distributed to local and international church and government leaders.
5. The
Joy of Welcoming International Visitors to the ELCJ
The ELCJ has been enjoying the visits of several international
groups in the last two months. In addition to the visits from
ELCA groups in the US, we have welcomed groups from the Swedish
Council of Churches, the Norwegian Council of Churches, and the
Wheatridge Foundation in the US, as well as journalists' groups
from various countries. During the time of these visits, the boards
of the Lutheran World Federation Vocational Training School and
of Augusta Victoria Hospital have been meeting. Also gathering
at this time has been the Consultative Committee for Land Development
on the Mount of Olives.
It is a great
pleasure to welcome all our guests and have them experience our
human, religious and political situation. You are always invited
and welcomed!
Blessed
Advent and Christmas greetings to you all from Bishop Younan and
the entire ELCJ family of congregations, schools, faculties, pastors,
staff and ELCJ members.
Noted
by Rev. Dr. Mary E. Jensen
Communications Assistant to Bishop Dr. Munib A Younan